“Thanksgiving – A Violation of Church and State?” by Chuck Norris

Is the government’s observance of Thanksgiving a violation of the separation of church and state?

This past week, a Newsweek/Washington Post editorial labeled presidential Thanksgiving Day proclamations as “cracks in the wall of separation.” The author explained, “The problem with these proclamations, it seems to me, is that they pave the way for public acceptance of gross violations of the constitutional separation of church and state.” What?!

Forget for a moment that nearly every president since George Washington (and the Continental Congress before him) has given Judeo-Christian proclamations for Thanksgiving (except between 1816 and 1861) and also has declared other national days of fasting and prayer. Secularists, such as the author of the editorial, get almost giddy every time they highlight that Thomas Jefferson rejected the notion of proclaiming Thanksgiving spirituals and prayers. But the truth is Jefferson was far from the modern-day secularist they make him out to be.

Sure, Jefferson was adamant (as we all should be) that there should be no federal subscription to any one form of religious sectarianism. That is largely what the First Amendment is all about — establishing the free exercise of religion and restricting sectarian supremacy in government, as well as government intrusion in churches.

But secularists make two grave mistakes when it comes to Jefferson and the First Amendment. First, they misconstrue his understanding of separation. Second, they overlook how Jefferson himself endorsed and intermingled religion and politics, even during his two terms as president. Let me explain, as I believe it is a timely reminder, given that we are experiencing a new round of battles in our Christmas culture war, too.

The phrase “separation of church and state” actually comes from a letter Thomas Jefferson wrote in 1802 to the Danbury Baptists. He told them that no particular Christian denomination was going to have a monopoly in government. His words, “a wall of separation between Church & State,” were not written to remove all religious practice from government or civic settings, but to prohibit the domination and even legislation of religious sectarianism.

Proof that Jefferson was not trying to rid government of religious (specifically Christian) influence comes from the fact that he endorsed the use of government buildings for church meetings and services, signed a treaty with the Kaskaskia Indians that allotted federal money to support the building of a Catholic church and to pay the salaries of the church’s priests, and repeatedly renewed legislation that gave land to the United Brethren to help their missionary activities among the American Indians.

Some might be completely surprised to discover that just two days after Jefferson wrote his famous letter citing the “wall of separation between Church & State,” he attended church in the place where he always had as president: the U.S. Capitol. The very seat of our nation’s government was used for sacred purposes. As the Library of Congress’ Web site notes, “It is no exaggeration to say that on Sundays in Washington during the administrations of Thomas Jefferson (1801-1809) and of James Madison (1809-1817) the state became the church.” Does that sound like someone who was trying to create an impenetrable wall of separation between church and state?

Original Link.

4 Responses to ““Thanksgiving – A Violation of Church and State?” by Chuck Norris”

  1. Greg P says:

    My question is…

    Do atheists celebrate Thanksgiving? If so, who do they thank?

    If not, then why aren’t they working while the rest of us are thanking God for our abundance. To them it’s just Thursday …. right?

  2. Beth says:

    Greg, Greg, Greg……..

    Surely, you know better than to question the atheists about holidays. 😉

    Every time I question why atheists celebrate Christmas (and I have done so every Christmas for several years), they always get their backs up. They deny Christ, yet celebrate His birthday, but when you call them on it, they get really mad for some reason. A little oxyMORON if you ask me. 😉

    I bet on Thanksgiving they get together to thank “their lucky stars” or something………

  3. My family gets together on Thanksgiving and Christmas. I enjoy spending time with my family, therefore I go to the family gatherings on the holidays. Why is that so difficult to understand?

  4. Steve says:

    It’s not hard to understand.
    We Christians just find it ironic that secularist and atheist fight tooth and nail against everything Christian, until it comes to something that will benefit them (i.e. a holiday), then they want on board.
    Kind of a hypocrisy if you ask me.
    I hope your Thanksgiving was wonderful. We appreciate your comments, as always.

Leave a Reply